|
Post by pedrofanforever45 on Apr 8, 2019 20:08:05 GMT -5
No the Sox absolutely shouldn't rush Dalbec.
However if Devers has another 20+ error season, then I think the Sox should give Devers a first base glove in spring training of 2020. Devers was also a -13 DRS guy last year too, if anyone wants to complain about the error stat.
Yes Devers makes good plays at third base too, but there's too many mistakes being made there. I'm not too sure if Devers will be sufficient enough to be a good third baseman.
A lot of Devers mistakes seems like they can be cleaned up if he made the switch to first base. Most of his errors seem to be throwing errors. Him getting the ball out of his glove seems to be a problem at times to make a throw (he was working with Pedrioa last year on this). You don't have to worry about those things a lot at first base.
If Dalbec can become even a guy who hits 25-30 homeruns and has a .200 average with a .330 OBP with good to great defense at third, then I think moving Devers to first base full-time (and part time 3B when Dalbec needs a break) is a solid plan for the Sox.
Devers already has 2 errors in 10 games in 2019. Something to keep a eye on this year. He needs to show definite improvement this year imo to be able to show he can stick there long-term.
|
|
|
Post by James Dunne on Apr 8, 2019 20:56:29 GMT -5
Speaking of Devers, he hit .300/.369/.575 with a 17.2% K rate in Double-A as a 20-year-old. It's a big jump from there to the majors, and it's tough to just assume that someone's rates are just going to stay the same as he climbs the ladder.
|
|
|
Post by philsbosoxfan on Apr 8, 2019 21:38:37 GMT -5
No the Sox absolutely shouldn't rush Dalbec. However if Devers has another 20+ error season, then I think the Sox should give Devers a first base glove in spring training of 2020. Devers was also a -13 DRS guy last year too, if anyone wants to complain about the error stat. Yes Devers makes good plays at third base too, but there's too many mistakes being made there. I'm not too sure if Devers will be sufficient enough to be a good third baseman. A lot of Devers mistakes seems like they can be cleaned up if he made the switch to first base. Most of his errors seem to be throwing errors. Him getting the ball out of his glove seems to be a problem at times to make a throw (he was working with Pedrioa last year on this). You don't have to worry about those things a lot at first base. If Dalbec can become even a guy who hits 25-30 homeruns and has a .200 average with a .330 OBP with good to great defense at third, then I think moving Devers to first base full-time (and part time 3B when Dalbec needs a break) is a solid plan for the Sox. Devers already has 2 errors in 10 games in 2019. Something to keep a eye on this year. He needs to show definite improvement this year imo to be able to show he can stick there long-term. Devers second error was on a one hop throw that Travis should have easily had instead of bobbling it.
|
|
|
Post by Chris Hatfield on Apr 8, 2019 22:12:18 GMT -5
Considering that he has a 35% strikeout rate and an unsustainable BABIP that mean his numbers are coming down at some point once we leave SSS land, not for a while. I don’t see why Dalbec can’t be a 35-40 home run, 100 RBI, 75 BB plus, .800 OPS guy per year...with 200ks and .220-.230 average. Along with good glove at 3b and a great arm. Ill take that I don't think you understand the unicorn you're describing. Joey Gallo is basically the only player in MLB that fits this description (and so precisely that I'm guessing it wasn't a coincidence, upon further thought). It's generally not great if you throw out a line for a guy and only one MLB player is able to do that, and it's a guy who has to use an 80 tool to do it. Last year, I looked at what players of that sort in MLB did in High A compared to Dalbec. He did not compare well. forum.soxprospects.com/post/320069/thread Let's look at AA: Gallo was in AA at age 20 and 21, and he hit .259/.365/.561 with 30 home runs in 437 PA - 6.9% (102 games), striking out 37.5% of the time. Dalbec, in AA at age 23 and 24, is hitting .264/.333/.512 with 7 home runs in 141 PA - 5.0% (33 games), striking out 36.9% of the time. His numbers compare decently in a SSS to Gallo so far, but a 32-point difference in OBP and a 49-point difference in slugging are bigger than you'd think. Plus the three-year age difference is pretty huge. It's just very hard to make such little contact and hit that many home runs without off-the-charts power like Gallo has (and Dalbec does not have).
|
|