SoxProspects News
|
|
|
|
Legal
Forum Ground Rules
The views expressed by the members of this Forum do not necessarily reflect the views of SoxProspects, LLC.
© 2003-2024 SoxProspects, LLC
|
|
|
|
|
Forum Home | Search | My Profile | Messages | Members | Help |
Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.
Celtics 2023 Offseason Thread
|
Post by redsoxfan2 on Oct 1, 2023 15:18:48 GMT -5
How I look at the off-season. + KP > Time Lord + Jrue > Smart
- Loss of Brogdon.
I'm very happy with the upgrades.
Random, probably unpopular thought. Bring in Dwight Howard as the 3rd big?
|
|
|
Post by Don Caballero on Oct 1, 2023 15:29:50 GMT -5
Bring in Dwight Howard as the 3rd big? I'd do that in a heartbeat.
|
|
|
Post by soxfansince67 on Oct 1, 2023 16:28:34 GMT -5
I'm bullish on the trade. Something big was needed
|
|
|
Post by umassgrad2005 on Oct 1, 2023 16:29:06 GMT -5
Yeah for me it's Smart, Brogdon, Robert Williams, Grant Williams, Gallinari, high 2nd round pick for Unicorn and Holiday.
You got older and you can't say more reliable because the Unicorn is injury prone, which is a much bigger issue without Robert Williams.
|
|
|
Post by umassgrad2005 on Oct 1, 2023 16:53:59 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by redsoxfan2 on Oct 1, 2023 16:59:45 GMT -5
Yeah for me it's Smart, Brogdon, Robert Williams, Grant Williams, Gallinari, high 2nd round pick for Unicorn and Holiday. You got older and you can't say more reliable because the Unicorn is injury prone, which is a much bigger issue without Robert Williams. Rob Williams is just as likely to go down with injury. In an ideal world, you have both and hope 1 can make it through, but Rob was far from healthy so it's just talent per talent comparison. Grant wasn't going to be here. Gallinari never played a minute for the Celtics so I don't consider that a loss. They never got to play him. I would take Jrue over Smart despite age. We also don't know how much Brogdon will be hampered by injury because that's why Smart isn't here to begin with. But they desperately need another big. That can't be under stated.
|
|
cdj
Veteran
Posts: 15,867
|
Post by cdj on Oct 1, 2023 19:25:06 GMT -5
They can fit Jalen Smith into the trade exception they have, that’s a solid guy to target imo
|
|
|
Post by philarhody on Oct 1, 2023 19:29:26 GMT -5
Home run baby. Brad has won every trade so far
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Oct 2, 2023 5:39:27 GMT -5
Obviously money going forward is doing to be an issue, which will be felt around the league not just in Boston. One interesting thing is teams above the second apron won’t be able to aggregate salaries, in trades, starting next year, but Boston will theoretically have 4 large salaries to work with so maybe that is part of their thinking… idk
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Oct 2, 2023 5:46:57 GMT -5
I do have to say, I love what Portland did here because F Liliard, the Heat and every NBA player who tries to say where they get traded to. Miami had nothing to offer and everyone still thought they’d get it done for a guy like Herro and scraps. Herro is a fine player but he has injury concerns and can’t play D. Also, good for the league stepping in to even the playing field by getting them to back off publicly saying the only place he’d show up is Miami.
It kind of sucks because I thought Liliard was loyal (he was), until he screwed things up as the end by demanding a trade publicly and doing it after the draft and free agency starting.
|
|
|
Post by jmei on Oct 2, 2023 6:44:06 GMT -5
I think you guys are underrating Jrue Holiday. He’s a perfect fit for this roster and his efficiency will tick up once he’s not asked to be the first or second offensive option/creator. Still one of the best defenders in the league with some positional flexibility (can guard Lillard, Maxey, Butler, Harden, etc.). Rob Williams still has a ton of potential but his injury history makes him unreliable and unclear whether he was going to play crunch time minutes on this roster. They probably gave up one pick too many but that’s what it took to keep him away from one of the other Eastern Conference contenders.
|
|
cdj
Veteran
Posts: 15,867
|
Post by cdj on Oct 2, 2023 7:52:10 GMT -5
I do have to say, I love what Portland did here because F Liliard, the Heat and every NBA player who tries to say where they get traded to. Miami had nothing to offer and everyone still thought they’d get it done for a guy like Herro and scraps. Herro is a fine player but he has injury concerns and can’t play D. Also, good for the league stepping in to even the playing field by getting them to back off publicly saying the only place he’d show up is Miami. It kind of sucks because I thought Liliard was loyal (he was), until he screwed things up as the end by demanding a trade publicly and doing it after the draft and free agency starting. They put on a masterclass with what they’ve turned Lillard into
|
|
mobaz
Veteran
Posts: 3,045
|
Post by mobaz on Oct 2, 2023 9:55:34 GMT -5
I do have to say, I love what Portland did here because F Liliard, the Heat and every NBA player who tries to say where they get traded to. Miami had nothing to offer and everyone still thought they’d get it done for a guy like Herro and scraps. Herro is a fine player but he has injury concerns and can’t play D. Also, good for the league stepping in to even the playing field by getting them to back off publicly saying the only place he’d show up is Miami. It kind of sucks because I thought Liliard was loyal (he was), until he screwed things up as the end by demanding a trade publicly and doing it after the draft and free agency starting. They put on a masterclass with what they’ve turned Lillard into I would have been so pissed to pay JGrant likely to appease Lillard and then have Lillard say he was done while the ink was drying. So Grant's contract is bloated but won't stop them from building at the same time.
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Oct 2, 2023 10:21:00 GMT -5
They put on a masterclass with what they’ve turned Lillard into I would have been so pissed to pay JGrant likely to appease Lillard and then have Lillard say he was done while the ink was drying. So Grant's contract is bloated but won't stop them from building at the same time. If Grant plays well his contract is tradable and it’s probably better for the young kids if they don’t suck so I guess that’s the glass half full look at things
|
|
|
Post by umassgrad2005 on Oct 2, 2023 10:21:43 GMT -5
Yeah for me it's Smart, Brogdon, Robert Williams, Grant Williams, Gallinari, high 2nd round pick for Unicorn and Holiday. You got older and you can't say more reliable because the Unicorn is injury prone, which is a much bigger issue without Robert Williams. Rob Williams is just as likely to go down with injury. In an ideal world, you have both and hope 1 can make it through, but Rob was far from healthy so it's just talent per talent comparison. Grant wasn't going to be here. Gallinari never played a minute for the Celtics so I don't consider that a loss. They never got to play him. I would take Jrue over Smart despite age. We also don't know how much Brogdon will be hampered by injury because that's why Smart isn't here to begin with. But they desperately need another big. That can't be under stated. Yeah that's the point, having Williams and the Unicorn protects you, nevermind gives you two big potential when both healthy. It's like people forgot the D wasn't very good last year till Robert Williams came back. Horford is old and declining. Everyone talks about Williams health, the Unicorn has missed a ton of games, so depth behind him matters. Grant wasn't going to be here because of the Unicorn trade and having 3 bigs. If you knew you were going to do this, I bet Stevens keeps him. That's what you traded, it matters because we went from crazy depth to a very top heavy team that lacks depth to overcome injuries. That matters with new CBA and because Stevens literally refuses to even make, nevermind develop first round picks. If this was Smart for Holiday there wouldn't be a single conversation going on, even given the age difference. Robert Williams is the most impactful defender I've ever seen. I don't care about trading Brogdon, but you just basically paid 4 first round picks for Holiday and took away our best defender, all for a 33 year old PG who was crap the last two years in playoffs. Created a big hole at center and downgraded your D, while hurting depth right when the new rules make it almost impossible to easily replenish it. Lillard was skilled enough to solve your offensive issues all by himself. Holiday requires changing everything and the team playing team basketball under a completely different offenses. It's not that it can't work, it's I don't trust our young inexperienced coach to easily pull that off. We got wins more last year based on talent than having a great brilliant coach.
|
|
|
Post by umassgrad2005 on Oct 2, 2023 10:30:25 GMT -5
Home run baby. Brad has won every trade so far No way he won trading two 2nds for Mike Muscala, that's a bad trade. I'd also question the Brogdon trade. A year later you want to trade him because he doesn't fit and get a trade canceled because teams worry about his health. Which is why he was cheap to begin with. Then with Holiday, it obviously a wait and see. You did just basically trade 4 first round picks for a 33 year old PG that the Bucks traded because he sucked in the playoffs the last two years. While trading our best defensive player on a team built to win with D. Only way that is a HR trade is if they win a championship. BTW he can opt out after this year. Which could be good or bad depending on what happens.
|
|
|
Post by umassgrad2005 on Oct 2, 2023 10:32:10 GMT -5
I do have to say, I love what Portland did here because F Liliard, the Heat and every NBA player who tries to say where they get traded to. Miami had nothing to offer and everyone still thought they’d get it done for a guy like Herro and scraps. Herro is a fine player but he has injury concerns and can’t play D. Also, good for the league stepping in to even the playing field by getting them to back off publicly saying the only place he’d show up is Miami. It kind of sucks because I thought Liliard was loyal (he was), until he screwed things up as the end by demanding a trade publicly and doing it after the draft and free agency starting. They put on a masterclass with what they’ve turned Lillard into Yes they did, very impressive given the Lillard will only go to Miami crap and the offers they were making.
|
|
mobaz
Veteran
Posts: 3,045
|
Post by mobaz on Oct 2, 2023 10:33:30 GMT -5
They put on a masterclass with what they’ve turned Lillard into Yes they did, very impressive given the Lillard will only go to Miami crap and the offers they were making. Okay, I have more thoughts. I'd actually be really excited about how this is turning out if I were a Blazers fan. Sucks the dude kind of burned his way out of town, but they are doing basically the opposite of the old Danny Ainge Bigger-Better trades: Lillard for Holliday and picks => Holliday for Brogdon and picks => Brodgon for X and likely picks. Plus Ayton, Timelord, NotNurkic, etc. Other than Brooklyn somehow turning Mikal Bridges into a star (that dude apparently needed his own team like Dave Grohl needed his own band) and the Gobert debacle I can't think of another recent big-name deal where the return is better than 75 cents on the dollar. Also interesting for those with ESPN Insider, Woj had a good breakdown of the details of the deal, including the fact that the Suns only knew they were trading with Portland and a Mystery Team. The Bucks INSISTED nothing leak because they didn't want to alienate Holliday if it fell through (a la Brogdon!). So the Suns knew the Nurkic/Ayton etc part, and that Lillard was going out elsewhere, but they were only told they'd be getting a Mystery Player from the 3rd team: Never heard of such a thing. But fun insider details!
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Oct 2, 2023 10:43:31 GMT -5
Sam Hauser becomes a lot more interesting. If he continues his progression there is zero reason why he’s not a legitimate real role player. He’s actually pretty solid defensively. I like good defense as much as they next guy but this team could still be very good defensively. Porzingus is a good drop defender and rim protector. Holiday is a better ball stopper than Smart, add in Tatum and White and Brown and Al, this isn’t a team that will or should get shredded defensively.
Offensively, is where they still needed to improve to not rely too much on Tatum and Brown. They should be better there too.
I think we may be overlooking Hauser and how “good” he can and should be. The shooting and size are important.
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Oct 2, 2023 10:50:22 GMT -5
I do consider Jordan Walsh a first round pick even tho they traded back to take him. It was good and necessary board maneuvering to replenish picks and they still go their guy.
|
|
|
Post by redsoxfan2 on Oct 2, 2023 10:58:04 GMT -5
Rob Williams is just as likely to go down with injury. In an ideal world, you have both and hope 1 can make it through, but Rob was far from healthy so it's just talent per talent comparison. Grant wasn't going to be here. Gallinari never played a minute for the Celtics so I don't consider that a loss. They never got to play him. I would take Jrue over Smart despite age. We also don't know how much Brogdon will be hampered by injury because that's why Smart isn't here to begin with. But they desperately need another big. That can't be under stated. Yeah that's the point, having Williams and the Unicorn protects you, nevermind gives you two big potential when both healthy. It's like people forgot the D wasn't very good last year till Robert Williams came back. Horford is old and declining. Everyone talks about Williams health, the Unicorn has missed a ton of games, so depth behind him matters. Grant wasn't going to be here because of the Unicorn trade and having 3 bigs. If you knew you were going to do this, I bet Stevens keeps him. That's what you traded, it matters because we went from crazy depth to a very top heavy team that lacks depth to overcome injuries. That matters with new CBA and because Stevens literally refuses to even make, nevermind develop first round picks. If this was Smart for Holiday there wouldn't be a single conversation going on, even given the age difference. Robert Williams is the most impactful defender I've ever seen. I don't care about trading Brogdon, but you just basically paid 4 first round picks for Holiday and took away our best defender, all for a 33 year old PG who was crap the last two years in playoffs. Created a big hole at center and downgraded your D, while hurting depth right when the new rules make it almost impossible to easily replenish it. Lillard was skilled enough to solve your offensive issues all by himself. Holiday requires changing everything and the team playing team basketball under a completely different offenses. It's not that it can't work, it's I don't trust our young inexperienced coach to easily pull that off. We got wins more last year based on talent than having a great brilliant coach. Just went back to look at it and, yes, KP did make it impossible to bring back Grant. With that said, I still don't think the team wanted to pay Grant what he got from Dallas either. His performance declined and wasnt in any consistent rotation during the playoffs. But it's more fair than I remembered to say KP hindered a Grant return and why a sign and trade was required. Jrue is a corresponding move to Lillard though. They needed premier perimeter defense after that trade and Marcus was already gone. The Celtics are also going all in because they have Tatum's contract coming up and they'll need to remove pieces in the near future so age isn't a major concern right now. KP, if healthy (big if), Points Allowed Per Pick-and-Roll 1. Anthony Davis (0.91) 2. Steven Adams (0.92) 3. Giannis Antetokounmpo (0.92) 4. Kristaps Porzingis (0.93) 5. Walker Kessler (0.93) One of the best drop P&R defenders in the NBA. And on offense: Top Post Scorers 1. Kristaps Porzingis (1.29) 2. Nikola Jokic (1.26) 3. Luka Doncic (1.15) 4. Joel Embiid (1.11) 5. Pascal Siakam (1.11) But, yes, they need depth badly because 96 year old Horford and KP is scary to be relying on. That's why I'm a fan of seeing if Dwight wants to come to Boston (even though he's 37).
|
|
cdj
Veteran
Posts: 15,867
|
Post by cdj on Oct 2, 2023 11:01:12 GMT -5
maybe we’ll get more calls now that we got rid of 2 of the non-stars that complained about everything to the refs
It’s one thing when Jayson does it to a ref, it’s another thing when Grant does it
|
|
|
Post by Don Caballero on Oct 2, 2023 11:19:30 GMT -5
Then with Holiday, it obviously a wait and see. You did just basically trade 4 first round picks for a 33 year old PG that the Bucks traded because he sucked in the playoffs the last two years. While trading our best defensive player on a team built to win with D. Only way that is a HR trade is if they win a championship. BTW he can opt out after this year. Which could be good or bad depending on what happens. Jrue Holiday is overall a much better defender than Rob is though. I think you're overrating Timelord a bit here friend, especially considering he's not a tall guy and that he relies on jumping and his knees could be toast.
|
|
|
Post by umassgrad2005 on Oct 2, 2023 11:31:40 GMT -5
Yeah that's the point, having Williams and the Unicorn protects you, nevermind gives you two big potential when both healthy. It's like people forgot the D wasn't very good last year till Robert Williams came back. Horford is old and declining. Everyone talks about Williams health, the Unicorn has missed a ton of games, so depth behind him matters. Grant wasn't going to be here because of the Unicorn trade and having 3 bigs. If you knew you were going to do this, I bet Stevens keeps him. That's what you traded, it matters because we went from crazy depth to a very top heavy team that lacks depth to overcome injuries. That matters with new CBA and because Stevens literally refuses to even make, nevermind develop first round picks. If this was Smart for Holiday there wouldn't be a single conversation going on, even given the age difference. Robert Williams is the most impactful defender I've ever seen. I don't care about trading Brogdon, but you just basically paid 4 first round picks for Holiday and took away our best defender, all for a 33 year old PG who was crap the last two years in playoffs. Created a big hole at center and downgraded your D, while hurting depth right when the new rules make it almost impossible to easily replenish it. Lillard was skilled enough to solve your offensive issues all by himself. Holiday requires changing everything and the team playing team basketball under a completely different offenses. It's not that it can't work, it's I don't trust our young inexperienced coach to easily pull that off. We got wins more last year based on talent than having a great brilliant coach. Just went back to look at it and, yes, KP did make it impossible to bring back Grant. With that said, I still don't think the team wanted to pay Grant what he got from Dallas either. His performance declined and wasnt in any consistent rotation during the playoffs. But it's more fair than I remembered to say KP hindered a Grant return and why a sign and trade was required. Jrue is a corresponding move to Lillard though. They needed premier perimeter defense after that trade and Marcus was already gone. The Celtics are also going all in because they have Tatum's contract coming up and they'll need to remove pieces in the near future so age isn't a major concern right now. KP, if healthy (big if), Points Allowed Per Pick-and-Roll 1. Anthony Davis (0.91) 2. Steven Adams (0.92) 3. Giannis Antetokounmpo (0.92) 4. Kristaps Porzingis (0.93) 5. Walker Kessler (0.93) One of the best drop P&R defenders in the NBA. And on offense: Top Post Scorers 1. Kristaps Porzingis (1.29) 2. Nikola Jokic (1.26) 3. Luka Doncic (1.15) 4. Joel Embiid (1.11) 5. Pascal Siakam (1.11) But, yes, they need depth badly because 96 year old Horford and KP is scary to be relying on. That's why I'm a fan of seeing if Dwight wants to come to Boston (even though he's 37). Yeah because we would go big with Horford and Williams, even though Horford showed massive decline for the first time last year in playoffs. So going forward you won't be able to play two bigs like that now that R. Williams is gone. Never been the biggest Grant fan, but if this trade was made before he leaves, I do believe they keep him. You have White, who has been much better as a defender in playoffs than Holiday the last two years. So I don't really get that opinion, heck I think Brown with his length would be a good fit defending Lillard if they stop the switch everything all the time D. That's a glass half full way of looking at the Unicorn and his D. Sure he does some things well, he's not even in the same ballpark as Robert Williams in overall D. His value is much more on offense. He won't stop people from driving or even thinking about it, like Williams did. I'd pass on Howard, Horford is still good guarding huge bigs like Embiid, which would be Howard's role. We need another guy that's mobile and can protect the rim. Why I'm highly intrigued by Queta, especially if they add low post scorers in the offense for the Unicorn. Great shot blocker, low post scorer and could really pass out of the post in College. He's now had a few years to adjust to the NBA, he might make a nice back up center.
|
|
|
Post by umassgrad2005 on Oct 2, 2023 11:39:26 GMT -5
Then with Holiday, it obviously a wait and see. You did just basically trade 4 first round picks for a 33 year old PG that the Bucks traded because he sucked in the playoffs the last two years. While trading our best defensive player on a team built to win with D. Only way that is a HR trade is if they win a championship. BTW he can opt out after this year. Which could be good or bad depending on what happens. Jrue Holiday is overall a much better defender than Rob is though. I think you're overrating Timelord a bit here friend, especially considering he's not a tall guy and that he relies on jumping and his knees could be toast. No guard can have the impact a big does, it's impossible as bigs can take away the easiest buckets and stop 2nd chance opportunities with high level rebounding . Eye test is backed up by advanced stats that show Holiday can't come close to having the impact Robert Williams does and it's not even close. Do you remember our D last year with Smart and White before Robert Williams came back? Those are two of the better defensive guards in the league and we were middle of the pack. Robert Williams came back and we just kept improving into a top 10 defense.
|
|
|