SoxProspects News
|
|
|
|
Legal
Forum Ground Rules
The views expressed by the members of this Forum do not necessarily reflect the views of SoxProspects, LLC.
© 2003-2024 SoxProspects, LLC
|
|
|
|
|
Forum Home | Search | My Profile | Messages | Members | Help |
Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.
|
Post by soxfansince67 on Jan 5, 2019 13:35:41 GMT -5
Without laying blame - particularly on a player of Kyrie's level - it could simply be a numbers thing - on a given team, with a boatload of talent, playing time will naturally be restricted...how each player's performance is impacted by limited minutes or varying usage times within the game has impacts - I think that's the main phenomenon we've witnessed this year. Last season it was all hands on deck and the natural talent on the roster performed to each player's potential more often. The discussions I've heard by commentators and color people and between game banter seems to indicate this in their views as well....just not enough minutes to go around when you have more than a starting line up's worth of talent. There were discussions about the need to do a bit of subtracting just to get the balance/numbers more set up for consistent success.
What makes the analysis so challenging is that the level of talent on the opposition changes game to game as well...lots to study and learn from this season and this team, that's for sure - and they can run the gamut from frustrating to brilliant in the blink of an eye.
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Jan 5, 2019 14:38:31 GMT -5
I think there’s some validity to the claim that the ball stops moving a bit when Kyrie is on the floor, but that doesn’t explain the incompetence of so many individual players on the team for large stretches of this season. It’s oversimplifying things to say that Kyrie being out is the reason they’re playing better. This team doesn’t have any shot at being a title contender if Kyrie isn’t healthy. They probably don’t have much of a shot at being one this year even if he is healthy, but you need top-tier talent to win championships in this league, and Kyrie is certainly that. Right, and you can’t blame one player playing less aggressively on another player, especial when said player has been aggressive on both ends. If that is the case, then you need to look first at the players who are being less aggressive. It’s no coincidence that said players are young guys still developing. If they want to be on title teams, then they better learn how to play with true high end talent and not play timid. There’s a reason Horford, Morris and Smart don’t give a crap who’s on the court with them, they are going to play their games regardless. Brown has taken it on the chin this season but the last 6 games or so he’s stepped things up and been aggressive no matter who he’s playing with.
|
|
|
Post by umassgrad2005 on Jan 5, 2019 18:09:03 GMT -5
Since Smart started and Stevens made efforts to take the ball out of Irvings hands to improve ball movement Brown has averaged 13.8 points while shooting .507 and .362 in 24.5 minutes in 13 games. Before the change he averaged 11.1 points while shooting .398 and .253 in 28.1 minutes in 19 games.
It's like I've said all year Brown needs good ball movement and people to help create for him. Playing with guys like Hayward, Rozier, and Horford helps Brown get better shots and more opportunities. The more this team passes the better he does. Has nothing to do with him being aggressive, like that ever made a player shoot better.
The well Irving does stop ball movement, yet its still on everyone else crap just makes no sense. It's been proven that this team and it's players as a whole do better when playing team ball. If Irving is hurting that, he's part of the problem, not everyone else.
I do agree the best Celtic team is Irving playing Celtic Basketball, we just have to get him to play that way.
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Jan 5, 2019 20:07:38 GMT -5
Three recent loses, 120, 127, 120 points allowed. The offense is looking good overall, it's our D lately. 4 days ago 🤔 Fact is they’ve been playing really well offensively for well over a month. These last 2 games against awful teams changes nothing. Dallas is literally the worst team in the NBA on the road and Minny is right behind them. Especially, since they’ve have plenty of games like them otherwise. Add: go ahead get your last word in because i will no longer be entertaining the Kyrie stops the ball narrative.
|
|
|
Post by Don Caballero on Jan 5, 2019 20:18:25 GMT -5
I think there’s some validity to the claim that the ball stops moving a bit when Kyrie is on the floor, but that doesn’t explain the incompetence of so many individual players on the team for large stretches of this season. It’s oversimplifying things to say that Kyrie being out is the reason they’re playing better. This team doesn’t have any shot at being a title contender if Kyrie isn’t healthy. They probably don’t have much of a shot at being one this year even if he is healthy, but you need top-tier talent to win championships in this league, and Kyrie is certainly that. This entire post is spot on and the part about guys playing poorly for good chunks of the season is to me the biggest difference. Guys are being able to have a bigger impact and I don't think that's because they're sharing the ball more or anything like that. Sharing the ball is the effect of everyone playing better in this situation and not the cause. Kyrie had to go hero ball a lot thus far because everyone around him except Morris have struggled badly at different points in the season.
|
|
|
Post by umassgrad2005 on Jan 6, 2019 15:25:43 GMT -5
Three recent loses, 120, 127, 120 points allowed. The offense is looking good overall, it's our D lately. 4 days ago 🤔 Fact is they’ve been playing really well offensively for well over a month. These last 2 games against awful teams changes nothing. Dallas is literally the worst team in the NBA on the road and Minny is right behind them. Especially, since they’ve have plenty of games like them otherwise. Add: go ahead get your last word in because i will no longer be entertaining the Kyrie stops the ball narrative. www.celticsblog.com/2019/1/3/18166805/celtics-improve-to-27-17-all-time-without-kyrie-irving-as-super-subs-shine-vs-wolves-video-nbaIt's everywhere and you seem to be one of the only people that think Irving doesn't hurt our ball movement. Looking good yea I believe that, I said Irving was improving. Yet we've never seen a great offense either and Irving has done this before then goes on a few game tear of going right back to his old ways. He's taking baby steps but we aren't close to playing full on Celtic Basketball with him either. Which is what these games highlight. Add a guy like Irving to the way they are playing and we should be one of the top offense in the league. That just doesn't happen though, the offense is like the same with and without him. Hopefully the gametape can help Irving understand how to blend his play with his teammates and our system. The use of quick cuts and passes, not pounding the rock and clear out iso play. That type of crap is ok every now and then, but not a huge levels. The one thing that gives me hope is when Irving wants to play team ball he can do it very effectively. Right now though it's like he has to force himself to do it. We won't reach our potential untill that becomes his normal way of playing.
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Jan 6, 2019 18:18:22 GMT -5
4 days ago 🤔 Fact is they’ve been playing really well offensively for well over a month. These last 2 games against awful teams changes nothing. Dallas is literally the worst team in the NBA on the road and Minny is right behind them. Especially, since they’ve have plenty of games like them otherwise. Add: go ahead get your last word in because i will no longer be entertaining the Kyrie stops the ball narrative. www.celticsblog.com/2019/1/3/18166805/celtics-improve-to-27-17-all-time-without-kyrie-irving-as-super-subs-shine-vs-wolves-video-nbaIt's everywhere and you seem to be one of the only people that think Irving doesn't hurt our ball movement. Looking good yea I believe that, I said Irving was improving. Yet we've never seen a great offense either and Irving has done this before then goes on a few game tear of going right back to his old ways. He's taking baby steps but we aren't close to playing full on Celtic Basketball with him either. Which is what these games highlight. Add a guy like Irving to the way they are playing and we should be one of the top offense in the league. That just doesn't happen though, the offense is like the same with and without him. Hopefully the gametape can help Irving understand how to blend his play with his teammates and our system. The use of quick cuts and passes, not pounding the rock and clear out iso play. That type of crap is ok every now and then, but not a huge levels. The one thing that gives me hope is when Irving wants to play team ball he can do it very effectively. Right now though it's like he has to force himself to do it. We won't reach our potential untill that becomes his normal way of playing. See this is where we disagree. We won’t reach our full potential until all the guys start playing better. I’ve been clear that Kyrie is far from a perfectly player. My contention with you is 3 fold: 1) placing the sole blame on Kyrie for other guys playing poorly. It’s just not fair and not true and that video you linked (good stuff by the way) agrees with me on that point. Sure there are things Kyrie needs to do better and has been doing better but the other guys need to play hard and aggressive no matter what. That’s on them as professional athletes. The veterans do but the younger guys get lost and that’s just reality of the NBA. 2) Arguing that the team is somehow better without Kyrie than with him. You argued this entire offseason that they were better with Rozier over Kyrie. Then you called Kyrie a net negative at one point this year. Assuming the numbers they give are right it shows their record is worse without Kyrie than with and how they are absolutely terrible on the road without Kyrie. Why? Because role players don’t win on the road consistently in the NBA. You need studs. The only way they had road success last year was against the equally young Sixers in the playoffs (1 OT win). 3) acting as if Kyrie just plays hero ball and doesn’t pass, just stands there and dribbles in isolation using the entire shot clock or jacking up a shot early. This just isn’t how he plays. You literally told me him driving to the hoop was him driving taking some out of control difficult shot because he never looks for contact or to pass. You called it something like a zero sum game if he misses his shot. Despite all that, it really comes down to the baffling notion that you put 100% of the blame for anyone’s issues on Kyrie and not on them having to adapt at all. This team is better with Kyrie than without him. It’s that simple. But yes they need to play better and he’s part of it just hardly all of it.
|
|
|
Post by umassgrad2005 on Jan 6, 2019 22:20:00 GMT -5
1) That video also talks about how guys sit around and watch Irving play iso ball. So how can you blame the other players and say its on them to play hard and agressive? I guess they could just not give Irving the ball.
2) Did I do that? Or did I agrue Rozier runs the offense better? I argued all offseason that Irving needed to play team ball more, up the pace, and blend into the Celtics offense. You know score within the offense.
Those records show like half the games without Irving as Playoff games. 19 of them in fact and the team went 11-8. They won 11 playoff games without Irving! They won two playoff series and this year shows the Sixers and Bucks are both really good teams. Crazy impressive stuff.
I'm not arguing they are better without Irving. It's the fact they are about the same that is crazy. You are mixing up last years playoffs with this year. It's that all those guys you keep saying need play harder, more aggressive and overall better do exactly that without Irving. Look at the Brown stats I posted, look at how Rozier plays without Irving. Take Harden off of the Rockets and they would fall a part.
I've also made it clear Irving isn't the only issue. Yet most of our issues have been solved with moving Hayward and Brown to the bench. Heck Hayward bouncing back also fixes a huge issue. The most glaring one left is how the teams plays totally different with Irving than Without him. It's why it's a huge talking point right now. Everyone finally sees it.
3) Are you saying Irving doesn't dominate the ball? I don't even know what to say overall about that. I think he does exactly what they talked about in the video.
Here's the thing with Irving he wants the team to play his way. He's said just that. Yea he's made some changes and has improved. Yet he still believes that, just like a Durant does in Golden State. If the team can play so well without you shouldn't you blend into the system rather than try and change it? You think the players need to step and up and play better at Irvings game. I think Irving needs to play our game more, the one that suits the rest of the team. That is going to be the best Celtic team. If this team sucked without Irving and could only win with him I'd side with you. Example the Lakers and teams like Houston. They suck without LeBron and Harden, so yea those guys need to play his style. That isn't the Celtics. I'd fully expect this team to have a very similar record if Irving was out the whole year! Hence they aren't playing close to the level they should with an Irving. That's on him and his different style. The same way I agree with Steve Kerr that Durant needs to blend into Golden States style, not try and change it.
Irving has made progress, but he's not even close to playing full Celtic Basketball all the time. You notice it like crazy when he's out. It's why I'd make him a full-time SG untill he can fully change. He plays a lot better team Basketball off the ball than with it. Even then he has some work to do.
This all comes down to what you think you need to win in the NBA team Basketball or ISO Basketball. I'm a team basketball guy, that is what made us great in last years playoffs. It's what made the big three era great. It's what has made the Warriors an all-time great team. If you want to be an ISO team you need to make some trades, this team isn't built to play that way. It was built to play Stevens style.
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Jan 7, 2019 6:58:38 GMT -5
1) That video also talks about how guys sit around and watch Irving play iso ball. So how can you blame the other players and say its on them to play hard and agressive? I guess they could just not give Irving the ball. Finally a real discussion... I’ll take this is pieces so not to confuse things as there are a lot of conversations within our posts. I will answer some over the course of the day so I’m not ignoring other things just trying to be more on point. Because when you just stand around when a guy has the ball you leave him with very few options. That’s why Kyrie talks about guys having to make cuts, set screens etc. The young guys need to play the game. You act like he’s a black hole with the ball; it’s just not the case and it’s hard to have a conversation when I have to start by pushing back against that point. The ball moves differently with Kyrie on the court but that’s not entirely his fault nor should it be an entirely bad thing. Kyrie has shown when guys move, screen and slash he gets them the ball. You want to say they stand around because of him hoarding the ball; I disagree with that being the reason and even if I accept that’s a reason it’s still inexcusable. You think they started playing better because they moved Smart and Morris into the starting lineup and I agree. You think that’s because they took the ball out of Kyrie hands; I think it’s because they put two veterans into the lineup that move and play hard no matter who they are playing with. Even if I concede Kyrie is now a shooting guard, if he were the black hole you paint him to be then he’d stop the offense once the ball hit his hands. It doesn’t because he doesn’t.
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Jan 7, 2019 7:37:30 GMT -5
2) Look at the Brown stats I posted, I saw your Jaylen Brown numbers and I think they are rather meaningless once you dig deeper into them. You’re using them to try and prove once he was taken out of the lineup and freed from Kyrie then he’s turned a corner. It’s just not true. He started improving before he was even taken out of the lineup. 5 of his last 7 starts were filled with more aggressive play and more efficient scoring. They made the switch and 3 of his next 9 games were this way meaning 6 of them were not. The last 5 games we have seen the high promise Jaylen Brown we get excited about. So in summary, a switch didn’t go off when he was moved to the bench. He showed signs of finding himself in the 2 weeks prior to that and it hasn’t been until the last 5 games he’s really shown us something. Jaylen Brown is all about being aggressive. He plays within his head too much. 19gp 11.1/39.8/25.3 5 of his last 7 games as a starter before the change he had much improved numbers - shot over 40% (4 of them over 57%) 9GP 12/43.5/31.3 ** 3 of these games he played well. The other 6 were all 37.5% shooting and under (mostly well under) 5GP 17/63.5/46.7
|
|
|
Post by umassgrad2005 on Jan 7, 2019 9:59:33 GMT -5
1) That video also talks about how guys sit around and watch Irving play iso ball. So how can you blame the other players and say its on them to play hard and agressive? I guess they could just not give Irving the ball. Finally a real discussion... I’ll take this is pieces so not to confuse things as there are a lot of conversations within our posts. I will answer some over the course of the day so I’m not ignoring other things just trying to be more on point. Because when you just stand around when a guy has the ball you leave him with very few options. That’s why Kyrie talks about guys having to make cuts, set screens etc. The young guys need to play the game. You act like he’s a black hole with the ball; it’s just not the case and it’s hard to have a conversation when I have to start by pushing back against that point. The ball moves differently with Kyrie on the court but that’s not entirely his fault nor should it be an entirely bad thing. Kyrie has shown when guys move, screen and slash he gets them the ball. You want to say they stand around because of him hoarding the ball; I disagree with that being the reason and even if I accept that’s a reason it’s still inexcusable. You think they started playing better because they moved Smart and Morris into the starting lineup and I agree. You think that’s because they took the ball out of Kyrie hands; I think it’s because they put two veterans into the lineup that move and play hard no matter who they are playing with. Even if I concede Kyrie is now a shooting guard, if he were the black hole you paint him to be then he’d stop the offense once the ball hit his hands. It doesn’t because he doesn’t. You don't have guys cut and set screens on iso plays RJP. They stand around the three point line to give the guy spacing. Morris and Smart do the exact samething. What your describing is what guys do when playing team ball and they do just that when they pass. Not when Irving goes one on one. He needs and wants space and a clear path to the basket. You can't argue that to a degree they have taken the ball out of Irvings hands. Only one reason you do that.
|
|
|
Post by umassgrad2005 on Jan 7, 2019 10:13:50 GMT -5
Brown has shot over 55% in 8 of his last 13 games. After zero 20 point games in his first 19 he has 5 in his last 13 games. His first two came right after he went to the Bench.
If you look at advanced stats like game score his high before moving to the bench was 12.5, he has topped that 5 times now including a 27.5 game score.
This isn't Brown shooting well like the games you point out on 6, 7, and 9 attempts. This is Brown playing like last years playoffs and shooting awesome on high attempts, hence after no 20 point games in the first 19 he has 5 in his last 13.
Heck during this stretch just look at his two starts, one with Irving, one without him. 6 points vs 21, .333 shooting vs .600. It's just like last year Brown played better without Irving. Playoff Brown opened my eyes and raised my expectations. He did things I didn't think he could last year. We didn't see that player to he went to the bench to play with Hayward and Rozier.
|
|
wcp3
Veteran
Posts: 3,862
|
Post by wcp3 on Jan 7, 2019 11:50:19 GMT -5
Yup, everything bad is Kyrie’s fault, and anytime guys play well it’s because Kyrie was out. Got it.
I’m curious how the Celtics were able to win 16 in a row last year with Kyrie dragging them down.
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Jan 7, 2019 13:20:59 GMT -5
Yup, everything bad is Kyrie’s fault, and anytime guys play well it’s because Kyrie was out. Got it. I’m curious how the Celtics were able to win 16 in a row last year with Kyrie dragging them down. Yes I’m not even gonna bother continuing. I don’t know how to even discuss someone telling me guys can’t cut or set screens for other cutters because a certain player has the ball. Other than a designed play, like at the end of the Philly game, we don’t see 4 guys on one side of the court watching Kyrie go ISO on the other. I thought we were getting somewhere...
|
|
|
Post by texs31 on Jan 7, 2019 15:03:52 GMT -5
"guys sitting around watching" sure sounds like a "them" problem not a "him" problem (unless "him" is Brad).
|
|
|
Post by jmei on Jan 7, 2019 16:06:23 GMT -5
I will gently suggest that we all try to move on from the Kyrie discussion. Understand and acknowledge that it continues to be an area of interest, but I think we've gotten to the "beating a dead horse" phase of things. At the very least, would appreciate if posters could please be mindful of not being overly repetitive and understanding that you don't have to reply to every post that you disagree with and that it's OK to just disagree. Thanks.
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Jan 7, 2019 16:20:05 GMT -5
I will gently suggest that we all try to move on from the Kyrie discussion. Understand and acknowledge that it continues to be an area of interest, but I think we've gotten to the "beating a dead horse" phase of things. At the very least, would appreciate if posters could please be mindful of not being overly repetitive and understanding that you don't have to reply to every post that you disagree with and that it's OK to just disagree. Thanks. I’m on board with this but I’d appreciate it if you were more sympathetic to animals feelings and would use the more acceptable verbiage of “feed a fed horse”. To be more woke please refer to the following:
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Jan 7, 2019 19:15:18 GMT -5
|
|
wcp3
Veteran
Posts: 3,862
|
Post by wcp3 on Jan 7, 2019 20:37:15 GMT -5
The Celts would be up by 30 right now if Kyrie wasn’t playing.
|
|
|
Post by Don Caballero on Jan 7, 2019 21:14:03 GMT -5
The Celts would be up by 30 right now if Kyrie wasn’t playing. Jaylen DID look better in the two games without Kyrie. I don't think they like each other much.
|
|
|
Post by soxfansince67 on Jan 7, 2019 21:34:00 GMT -5
Just listening and watching the box score - lots of balance, consistent lead - Brown does stand out as being the one left out (5 fouls, only 4 points)....the mix on this team, when most are healthy, just may not be a good fit for him. (yes, I know - a one point graph, just tonight's game).
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Jan 7, 2019 21:53:01 GMT -5
The Celts would be up by 30 right now if Kyrie wasn’t playing. Jaylen DID look better in the two games without Kyrie. I don't think they like each other much. He also looked better in the 3 games before that with Kyrie.
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Jan 7, 2019 21:55:04 GMT -5
Season high 37 assists imagine how many they would have had.
|
|
|
Post by Don Caballero on Jan 7, 2019 22:04:45 GMT -5
He also looked better in the 3 games before that with Kyrie. I know, I wasn't being serious (although JB is by all reports a nerd and Kyrie is a truther so that could spell trouble). It's been a maddening inconsistent season for Jaylen, it would help if he was able to struggle while not looking unplayable during his off nights.
|
|
|
Post by rjp313jr on Jan 8, 2019 2:55:29 GMT -5
He also looked better in the 3 games before that with Kyrie. I know, I wasn't being serious (although JB is by all reports a nerd and Kyrie is a truther so that could spell trouble). It's been a maddening inconsistent season for Jaylen, it would help if he was able to struggle while not looking unplayable during his off nights. My bad, misunderstood. His body language is just bad as well. Idk, love the guy but he’s the type that should always have high energy in my opinion and it just feels too often he doesn’t. The gifts are there
|
|
|